JOURNAL · DESIGN · NOV 2026
Journal / Design · 5 min read
● DESIGN · 5 MIN

Our Brand Identity Process: The 6 Decisions We Make Before Anyone Opens Figma

Nov 7, 2026Published
Team RedmonkAuthor
DesignCategory
5 minReading time

Most brand identity reviews fall apart over a logo. That's the wrong place for them to fall apart. By the time a founder is staring at three logo options and feeling nothing, the real problem happened weeks earlier: nobody made the decisions that should have come before a single mark got drawn.

This post covers the six decisions we force on every brand identity project at Redmonk, before anyone touches Figma, and two examples from work we did this year that show why the order matters.

Decision 1: Who is this brand allowed to annoy?

Every strong identity irritates somebody. If a brand works for everyone, it usually means nothing to anyone. We ask clients directly: who is allowed to find this brand too loud, too plain, too expensive-looking, too serious? If the honest answer is "nobody, we want everyone to like it," the project is not ready to start. We had a SaaS client this year insist their brand needed to "appeal to enterprise buyers and scrappy startups equally." It couldn't, and once we got specific about which buyer actually signs the cheque, the rest of the decisions got easier.

Decision 2: Loud or quiet?

Not every brand should compete for attention. A compliance or fintech product usually earns more trust by being quiet, consistent, and slightly boring on purpose. A consumer app fighting for five seconds of attention on a crowded feed needs to be loud. We pick one lane in writing before any visual work starts, because "make it stand out, but also feel calm and trustworthy" is the brief that produces a brand nobody can describe in one sentence six months later.

Decision 3: One typeface or two?

This sounds like a production detail. It isn't. One typeface, used at different weights and sizes, reads as disciplined and is cheap to maintain across a website, a deck, and packaging. Two typefaces, paired well, buy you more personality but cost more in every template someone builds after we leave. We ask the client to pick discipline or personality on purpose, not by accident three months into using the brand, when someone on their team adds a third font to a slide deck because nobody ever said not to.

Decision 4: Does color carry meaning, or is it decoration?

Two clients came to us this year with almost the same line in their brief: "something bold and modern." One of them, a B2B logistics platform, ended up with a near-monochrome identity, charcoal and a single warning-orange used only for one specific thing: anything the product needs you to act on right now. The orange shows up on three screens in their whole product. That restraint was the brand decision. The other, a D2C wellness brand, got a full, saturated palette because color itself was the product's personality, used everywhere, not saved for anything. Same brief, opposite answers, because we asked what job color was supposed to do before picking any.

Decision 5: What does this look like on a bad day?

Most brand presentations show the identity at its best: perfect photography, perfect copy, generous whitespace. We insist on testing every identity against its worst realistic case before sign-off: a support ticket email, a cramped mobile checkout screen, a black-and-white printed invoice, a notification badge at 16 pixels. A wordmark that only works at 200 pixels on a white background isn't a finished identity, it's a poster. If a logo falls apart the first time it has to share space with a form field or a courier's print queue, that's a brand that will quietly get redesigned by committee within a year, usually badly.

Decision 6: Who signs off, and when?

This is the decision that actually prevents scope creep, not a clause in a contract. Before we show a single concept, we agree in writing who has final sign-off and at which stage: the founder, a co-founder, a board member, a marketing lead. We've had identity projects stall for three weeks because a product that was "approved" by the founder got re-opened by a co-founder who saw it for the first time at round three. That isn't a creative failure, it's a process failure, and it's entirely avoidable by naming the approver before concept work starts, not after.

The takeaway

None of these six decisions requires design skill to make. They require someone willing to be specific and a little uncomfortable before the fun part starts. Most of the brand identity disagreements we've seen in six years running this studio trace back to one of these six questions never getting a real answer, and the logo getting blamed for it instead.

If you're briefing an agency for identity work, bring answers to these six questions into the first call, even rough ones. It will save you a redesign in eighteen months. For the longer version of how we run a first client brief end to end, see our guide on how to brief a design agency (redmonk.in/blog/how-to-brief-a-design-agency) so scope doesn't creep later.

Working on a brand identity that needs to hold up past the pitch deck? Start a project (redmonk.in/contact-us) with Redmonk's design team (redmonk.in/design).

● ENJOYED THIS?

Got a project we should build together?

Let's talk ↗